A board can meet all governance standards but still be ineffective
By Rebecca Perrone, MAICD, Managing Director, Brooker Consulting
7 October 2026
From the Search Room
Most Boards measure their own effectiveness the same way they’d measure compliance: charter reviewed, skills matrix current, meetings attended, evaluation completed. Tick every box, and the Board is, on paper, effective.
Sitting in enough of these rooms tells you those two things aren’t the same measurement at all.
What actually happens
The annual board evaluation goes out, usually a survey, sometimes a structured interview. It asks about process: are papers arriving on time, is the agenda well run, is the skills mix right. Those questions get good answers, because they’re the questions the Board already knows how to answer well. What they rarely ask is whether anyone challenged the CEO this year, whether one or two voices quietly dominate every discussion, or whether a director has disagreed with the room and said so out loud.
Executives themselves don’t rate the outcome highly even when the process looks healthy. Only 41% rate their board’s overall effectiveness as excellent or good, according to governance platform Diligent’s research on board evaluation. That’s a low number for a function most boards believe they’re managing well.
A fair defence
Structured, process-based evaluation exists for a reason. It’s defensible, it’s comparable year on year, and it gives a Board something concrete to act on: recruit for a missing skill, fix a meeting cadence, tidy an agenda. None of that is wasted effort. It’s just not the same thing as effectiveness.
Where it stops working
Process compliance can rise every year while the actual quality of boardroom debate stays flat or gets worse, and nothing in a standard evaluation would catch that. More than half of directors, per a Global Network of Directors Institutes survey, consider board evaluations critical to improving performance, yet a large share of the same directors say they don’t act on what those evaluations find. Disclosure of formal evaluation processes among S&P 500 companies rose from 37% in 2018 to 52% in 2022. Doing the evaluation is becoming standard practice. Doing anything with it, less so.
The riskiest version of this is a Board that has never had a genuinely uncomfortable disagreement in the room. That can look like harmony from the outside and get read as evidence of a well-functioning Board. From the inside, it’s often evidence that nobody has tested an assumption in a long time, and the checklist has no line item for that.
What the strongest Boards do differently
They add a small number of behavioural questions to the evaluation that a process checklist can’t answer on its own: when did we last change our mind on something material because a director pushed back, who in this room speaks last and does everyone wait for them, and what did we decide this year that we’d have decided differently a year earlier. Answering those honestly says more about effectiveness than any skills matrix.
They also close the loop publicly, even briefly, on what the evaluation found and what changed as a result, which is the part most boards skip. A finding that goes nowhere trains directors to stop being candid on the next survey.
One move worth trying
At the next board evaluation, add one open question that isn’t about process: describe a moment this year when the Board changed its view because of something a director said in the room. If nobody can answer it with a specific instance, that’s a more honest effectiveness score than anything else on the form.
A Board can be fully compliant and still be quiet in exactly the moments that matter. Compliance is what a checklist can see. Effectiveness is what happens when someone in the room is willing to disagree, and whether the Board actually changes course because of it.
Brooker Consulting works with Boards on CEO appointments, including interim and interim-to-permanent transitions.
If this piece was useful, I would welcome a conversation.
Sources
- “Board evaluations: A guide to assessing performance”, Diligent: https://www.diligent.com/resources/blog/board-evaluations-assessing-board-101
- “Board evaluation: why many boards resist”, Boardworks (citing a Global Network of Directors Institutes report and S&P 500 disclosure data): https://www.boardworks.nz/resources/could-do-better-make-board-reviews-count/
Previous news articles:
- Non-profit executive search: the cost of getting values wrong
- Most Boards decide what CEO success looks like after the CEO has started
- Higher education executive search: competing for leaders beyond salary
- Healthcare executive search: appointing leaders for complexity and change
- A board can meet all governance standards but still be ineffective
Find your next leader with Brooker

Alternatively, contact:
Rebecca Perrone
Managing Director
P: 0429 381 277
E: rebecca@brookerconsulting.com.au