The hardest executive roles to fill in Australia right now sit in health. Not because leaders don’t exist, but because the brief is changing faster than the market. 

Every health board knows the feeling. A chief executive departure is announced, the search begins with confidence, and the shortlist that arrives tells you something is wrong. The candidates are credible, their careers are real, and yet none of them is obviously built for what your organisation now faces.

The problem is rarely the candidates. It is the brief. Health is in the middle of the most significant redesign of its operating environment in a generation, and the leadership profile that served boards well five years ago does not describe the leader the sector needs next. Healthcare executive search in Australia has become difficult not because talent has vanished, but because boards and search processes keep hiring for a role that no longer exists.

This article is for the boards of health services, Primary Health Networks, aged care providers and community health organisations. It sets out what has changed, why appointments keep going wrong, and what to look for when the next vacancy lands on your agenda.

The health sector is rebuilding its operating model

Consider what has changed around your executive team in the past two years alone.

The National Health Reform Agreement Addendum 2026 to 2031, signed by all governments in February 2026, replaces the old base plus growth funding model with a new glide path funding model from 1 July 2026, backed by up to $219.6 billion over five years. That is more money, but it arrives attached to a reform agenda: a Service Model Reform Funding Stream designed to shift care out of hospital walls, and a funding environment that expects measurable value, not activity.

In aged care, the new Aged Care Act commenced on 1 November 2025 alongside the Support at Home program, introducing a rights-based framework and a stricter regulatory model for providers. Aged care boards are now operating under rules that did not exist when most sitting chief executives were appointed.

Around both sit forces that predate any single reform: chronic workforce shortages, an ageing population with complex comorbidities, digital health maturity as a board-level expectation, and consumers who expect health services to behave like the modern services they experience everywhere else.

None of this is news to health boards. What is less often said aloud is the cumulative effect on the executive role. Today’s health chief executive is leading a funded business through a funding transition, in public, with a workforce in short supply, under a regulator with sharper teeth. The brief has compounded.

Why the brief has outpaced the market

For most of the past two decades, the profile of a successful health chief executive was reasonably stable: a strong operator who could run services within a funded budget, manage a demanding board and keep the department comfortable.

That person is no longer sufficient, and the market has not yet caught up. Three gaps show up repeatedly in health searches:

  1. The experience gap. Leaders with deep experience of the old funding model outnumber, by a wide margin, leaders who have led an organisation through a funding transition of this kind. Boards that treat transition experience as optional are selecting from yesterday’s market.
  2. The capability gap. The skills boards now need are system leadership, workforce strategy, digital fluency and genuine consumer partnership, and they are rarely visible in a CV written for appointments a decade ago. Searches that screen on titles rather than evidence of these capabilities produce shortlists that look right and perform poorly.
  3. The appetite gap. Many of the leaders best equipped for the current environment are declining to put themselves forward. They are already employed, they know exactly how hard these roles are, and they will only move for a board that demonstrates it understands the job. A search that cannot speak credibly about the role will not persuade them.

This is where a dedicated executive search firm can support. Recruiting within the sector from 1999 to today, Brooker Consulting has seen each of these gaps open and close first-hand. We understand the changes and challenges of the modern brief, and we know how to find the right leader for your organisation. 

The churn problem in Healthcare nobody names

The research on Australian health leadership is sobering. Studies of hospital chief executives have found average tenures of one to two years, with an estimated 25-50% of CEO resignations in Australian hospitals effectively involuntary. Every board in health knows an organisation where the revolving door has become the strategy.

Churn is expensive in any sector. In health, it is compounding. Every unplanned departure adds months of interim leadership, stalls reform commitments made to funders, and triggers a quiet exodus of executives who report to the chair that just spun. Hospital CEO recruitment that starts from scratch each time, with a fresh brief and no pipeline, guarantees the cycle repeats.

Boards that are serious about breaking the cycle treat succession as continuous and search as a discipline, not an event. They keep a live view of internal and near-market candidates, test readiness before it is needed, and when a search does run, they run it well.

Capabilities health boards should look for now

Strip away the sector jargon and the modern health leadership brief rests on five capabilities. Test every candidate, internal and external, against all five.

  1. Stakeholder fluency at scale. Ministers, departments, regulators, primary care partners, community, unions, media. Health chief executives operate in the most stakeholder-dense environment of any sector in Australia. Ask how they have repaired a damaged relationship, not just maintained a good one..
  2. Leading through transition, not just stability. Ask for a specific funding or operating model change the candidate has led, what broke along the way, and what they would do differently. Leaders who have only ever run services inside a settled model will find the next five years disorienting.
  3. Clinical credibility without clinical capture. The chief executive does not need to be a clinician, but they must be able to hold their own with clinical leaders, understand quality and safety at governance level, and make decisions that clinicians will accept even when they disagree. Equally, a leader captured by the clinical voice, unable to make the calls the organisation needs, is as dangerous as one who ignores it.
  4. Workforce strategy as core business. Workforce is no longer an HR agenda item; it is the binding constraint on everything your organisation promises. Look for evidence of building pipeline, retaining scarce specialists, and holding care quality while vacancies persist.
  5. Financial discipline in a funded system. The new funding arrangements reward organisations that can demonstrate value to funders and adapt their service model as money moves. The chief executive needs commercial instincts without commercial blind spots, able to run a margin conversation and a mission conversation in the same breath.

Where health searches go wrong

Four patterns account for most failed health appointments. None of them is inevitable.

  1. Promoting the best clinician into the chair. It is the sector’s most honoured tradition and its most reliable mis-hire. Clinical eminence is not executive capability, and the transition is far harder than it looks. Internal clinical leaders absolutely can become chief executives, but only when the board invests in developing and testing that transition rather than assuming it.
  2. Writing yesterday’s brief. If your position description could have been written in 2018, your search is addressing the wrong problem. Pressure-test the brief against what the organisation faces under the new funding and regulatory settings, and against the five capabilities above, before a single candidate is approached.
  3. Engaging a generalist for a specialist role. A search firm that cannot hold a conversation about your sector will not persuade the small pool of serious candidates to engage, and cannot assess them once they do. This is the case for specialist healthcare executive search firms, and the test is simple: ask the firm to describe the current pressures on your part of the sector unprompted. The difference between firms will be immediately apparent.
  4. Pricing the role off-market. Health executive remuneration sits in a narrow band between what public sector frameworks permit and what the market will accept. Boards that guess at this, or benchmark against the wrong comparator set, discover the problem at offer stage. Defensible, current, like-for-like remuneration data is part of a search, not an afterthought to it.

Partnering with the right executive search firm provides you with the ability to gain up-to-date remuneration benchmarking insights and to ensure you price your role competitively.

Segment by segment: where the brief sharpens

The previously mentioned capabilities apply across health, but each part of the sector adds its own weight.

  • Health services are absorbing the funding transition and the shift of care into community settings. Boards should weigh system leadership: can this candidate lead an organisation whose role in the local system is being redefined while it happens?
  • Primary Health Networks are commissioning organisations whose value depends on partnerships no one controls. Look for evidence of influencing without authority, and of making commissioning decisions that are defensible to the department and the community alike.
  • Aged care providers are operating under the new Act, the new regulatory model and Support at Home, with an aged care royal commission still in living memory. Regulatory credibility and reform leadership are not optional extras here; they are the job.
  • Community health organisations balance mission, thin margins and rising demand. The right leader protects the mission while running the discipline of a funded business, and boards should test for both, not one at the expense of the other.

What specialist health search looks like

When your board engages a search partner for a health appointment, expect the process to reflect the sector, not just the methodology described in our guide for boards choosing an executive search partner.

Direct approach matters most in health, because the leaders you want are employed, cautious and constantly approached. A specialist firm reaches them through reputation and sector standing, and knows which leaders can work with a board rather than merely tolerate one.

Assessment must include the health-specific layers: clinical governance literacy, quality and safety instinct, and stakeholder testing that reflects how the role is actually experienced, not how the position description reads it.

And because health appointments usually fail slowly and quietly, the process should not end at announcement. Structured onboarding, first hundred days support and post-appointment contact are where a good appointment is protected, not just made.

Your next step

Start with our Board Guide, written for chairs and directors facing exactly this moment. The boards that navigate the next five years of health reform well will not be the ones that were luckiest with succession timing. They will be the ones that understood the leadership brief had changed, and searched accordingly.

With more than 25 years advising health, aged care and community health boards on CEO, board and C-suite appointments, we know the leaders your organisation needs next, and we know how to reach them.
If a chief executive or executive appointment is on your horizon, contact Brooker Consulting for a confidential discussion. 

Brooker Consulting works with Boards on CEO appointments, including interim and interim-to-permanent transitions.

If this piece was useful, I would welcome a conversation.


Previous news articles:

Find your next leader with Brooker

    Rebecca Perrone profile photo

    Alternatively, contact:

    Rebecca Perrone
    Managing Director
    P: 0429 381 277
    E: rebecca@brookerconsulting.com.au